Discomfort Glare Cut-off Values from Field and Laboratory Studies

For the application of discomfort glare metrics, a categorisation is used, dividing the metric scale into categories of perception. These categories are separated by borderline values, or so-called cut-off values. Recent literature shows that these cut-off values are lower when they are derived from field study data than those derived from laboratory study data.

To investigate this further, the data from one field study and two laboratory studies was used to derive and compare cut-off values corresponding to three borderlines. The results show that the field study cut-off values were systematically lower than the laboratory study ones, implying that discomfort glare is reported at lower stimulus magnitudes in the field.

Although further research is required on that topic, several hypotheses are discussed in order to explain the gap between cut-off values derived from field data and cut-off values derived from laboratory data. Recommendations for future studies are also provided.